Organic Versus Inorganic Management on the Yield and Soil Fertility of Irrigated Lowland Rice

Michelle  C. Quimbo,; Cezar  P. Mamaril,; Kathy Loren  S. Tafere,

Organic Versus Inorganic Management on the Yield and Soil Fertility of Irrigated Lowland Rice

Michelle C. Quimbo | Cezar P. Mamaril | Kathy Loren S. Tafere

Abstract:

Organic farming is being promoted by advocates to sustain and improve soil fertility compared to conventional farming that uses inorganic fertilizers and pesticides. The study was conducted to determine the effect of pesticide and fertilizer management practices on grain and straw yields, yield components, and soil fertility of irrigated lowland rice. The experiment was conducted for three consecutive seasons (2009-2010) at Los Baños, Laguna, Philippines. It was laid out in a Split Plot design consisting of two main plots: with pesticides (M1) and without pesticides (M2), and four subplots: control (T1), organic fertilizer only (T2), inorganic fertilizer only (T3), and one-half (½) rate of inorganic plus ½ rate of organic fertilizers (T4), with four replications. Generally, pesticide application did not affect the yield and yield components. Plots applied with inorganic and one-half rate of combined organic and inorganic fertilizers had significantly higher grain yields than the control and organic only fertilizer treatments. Application of limiting nutrients through inorganic fertilizers helps to correct most of soil deficiencies such as phosphorus and sulfur compared to the use of organic fertilizer alone. Combining organic materials such as compost and rice straw with inorganic fertilizers at one-half rates is an effective strategy to attain yields comparable to pure inorganic application to sustain soil fertility.

References:

AKTAR M.W., D. SENGUPTA, A. CHOWDHURY. 2009. Impact of pesticides use in agriculture: their benefits and hazards. Interdiscip Toxicol. 2009 March; 2(1): 1-12. Published online 2009 March. doi: 10.2478/v10102-009-0001-7.
CAPATI A.M.B. 1983. Improving the fertility of wetland rice soils by straw and water management. MS thesis, University of the Philippines Los Baños, Laguna, Philippines.
CASTILLO M.B., E.S. PATERNO, P.B. SANCHEZ, R.B. BADAYOS, P.C. STA. CRUZ. 2011. Enhancing Lowland Rice (Oryza sativa L.) Production Through Management of Rice Straw During the Fallow Period. MS Thesis, University of the Philippines Los Baños.
COSICO W.C. 2010. Overview of organic fertilizer use in rice in the Philippines. In: Revisiting the Organic Fertilizer Issue in Rice, Annual Rice Forum 2009. Asia Rice Foundation, College, Laguna 4031, Philippines. Pp. 1-15.
DESCALSOTA J.P., C.P. MAMARIL, G.O. SAN VALENTIN, A.L. AYO, T.M. CORTON and S.R. OBIEN. 2002. Minus-One Element Technique of diagnosing nutrient limitations and balancing fertilizer application in lowland rice soils. PhilRice Technical Bulletin. 6(2):1-6. Muñoz, Nueva Ecija: Philippine Rice Research Institute.
JAVIER E.F., J.M. MARQUEZ, F.S. GROSPE, H.F. MAMUCOD, R.E. TABIEN. 2002. Three-year effect of organic fertilizer use on paddy rice. Philippine Journal of Crop Science 2002, 27(2):11-15, Copyright 2004, Crop Science Society of the Philippines.
LALES J.S. 2008. Ten-year productivity of irrigated lowland rice under different levels of organic and inorganic fertilizers. Philippine Journal of Crop Science 2008, 33(2):59-74, Copyright 2008, Crop Science Society of the Philippines.
MAGALLONA E.D. 1989. Effects of Insecticides in Rice Ecosystems in Southeast Asia. In: Ecotoxicology and Climate. Published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
MAMARIL C.P., M.B. CASTILLO, L.S. SEBASTIAN. 2009. Facts and myths about organic fertilizers. Maligaya, Science City of Muñoz, Nueva Ecija: Philippine Rice Research Institute. 118 p.
MAMARIL C.P., M.S. CABRERA, D.I. ESTRELLA, E.M. DE GUZMAN. 1988. Combined use of inorganic and organic nitrogen fertilizers in lowland rice. Paper presented at the International Symposium on Balanced Fertilization on November 7-12, 1988 at Beijing, China.
NWILENE F.E., A. TOGOLA, O.E. OYETUNJI, A. ONASANYA, G. AKINWALE, E. OGAH, E ABO, M. UKWUNGWU, A. YOUDEOWEI, N.WOIN. 2011. Is Pesticide Use Sustainable in Lowland Rice Intensification in West Africa? Pesticides in the Modern World - Risks and Benefits (M. Stoytcheva, ed), ISBN: 978-953-307-458-0, InTech, Available from: http://www.intechopen.com/books/pesticides-in-the-modern-world-risks-andbenefits/is-pesticide-use-sustainable-in-lowland-rice-intensification-in-west-africa. pp 331-320.
PINGALI P.L. 1995. An overview of results from a multiciplinary study in the Philippines. In: Impact of pesticides on farmer health and the rice environment. Natural Resource and Management Policy. United States of America.
TILO, S.N and G.O. SAN VALENTIN. 1984. Crop residues/farm manures. Mimeographed report. Los Baños, Laguna: University of the Philippines Los Baños-Farming Systems and Soil Resources Institute.